i've watched them both play numerous times and romo is a much better player if you think eli is better because his team won a ring thats your opinion and I dont agree. did you watch those playoffs?? I did.....
is trent difer and eli better than moon and marino not a chance, 1 ring means shit especially the way his team won
is trent difer and eli better than moon and marino not a chance, 1 ring means shit especially the way his team won
Personally, believe RINGS WON to be only part of the equation won evaluating a QB............... having said that, when comparing RIVERS to BIG BEN I totally agree with DANTE on this one, BEN's two rings in hand enables him to surpasses RIVERS at this point in time in determining who the better QB to date has been and who has had the better overall career.
If both had ZERO rings, would rate Rivers ahead of Big Ben, but in this particular case, the two rings won by BIG BEN enables him to sit a notch or two above Rivers.
Big Ben has been a solid, solid playoff performer in his young career to date.
imp:
I will disagree in this case because IMHO, Big Rapist Ben won those Rings because of the Team he had.
And SB XL was a Joke for him... he had something like a 23 QB Rating !!
No, I'm not missing any numbers in that Rating... 23
So, IMO ... he's a good QB, not a Great one...... and he has been helped by the Team that he has around Him.
football is a total team sport to begin with, but what he does at crunchtime is what start's to seperate him from alot of other qb's. they had more play's of 20+ yds this season, which led the nfl....he might not be the flashy type qb like some of the rest, but he know's how to get the job done when it matter's most. esp when needing a last drive to win a game. roger's this yr in the playoff's had to sit on the bench during two of his gms, phil and chi, to watch his def close out the win for the team instead of him doing it while being on offense....
http://www.jsonline.com/blogs/sports/115293399.html
Romanowski says Rodgers the NFL's best
By Bob Wolfley of the Journal Sentinel
Feb. 4, 2011 11:43 a.m. |
Dallas - Former linebacker Bill Romanowski thinks the Steelers' defense has the edge over the Packers' defense but the Packers' own the edge on offense.
And, oh yeah, that Rodgers guy is pretty good.
"Clearly, statistics say Pittsburgh's defense is the best," Romanowski said during an interview in the media center. "But there are so many things that go into it. The amount of injuries that Green Bay has dealt with and overcome - but I give the edge to Pittsburgh.
"But sometimes your best defense is a great offense," Romanowski said. "I give the edge to Green Bay on offense. I think Aaron Rodgers is the best quarterback in the NFL because of his fundamentals, because there is not a throw he can't make. He can throw on the run both directions, which is really hard to do. He's great in the pocket. He's very calm and cool. I am really, really impressed."
Romanowski, 44, was a member of the Denver Broncos who vanquished the Packers, 31-24, in Super Bowl XXXII in San Diego.
When he was asked if the 1997 season Super Bowl was the highlight of his playing career, Romanowski didn't say a word.
He just held up his hand with the Super Bowl ring on it.
Romanowski says Rodgers the NFL's best
By Bob Wolfley of the Journal Sentinel
Feb. 4, 2011 11:43 a.m. |
Dallas - Former linebacker Bill Romanowski thinks the Steelers' defense has the edge over the Packers' defense but the Packers' own the edge on offense.
And, oh yeah, that Rodgers guy is pretty good.
"Clearly, statistics say Pittsburgh's defense is the best," Romanowski said during an interview in the media center. "But there are so many things that go into it. The amount of injuries that Green Bay has dealt with and overcome - but I give the edge to Pittsburgh.
"But sometimes your best defense is a great offense," Romanowski said. "I give the edge to Green Bay on offense. I think Aaron Rodgers is the best quarterback in the NFL because of his fundamentals, because there is not a throw he can't make. He can throw on the run both directions, which is really hard to do. He's great in the pocket. He's very calm and cool. I am really, really impressed."
Romanowski, 44, was a member of the Denver Broncos who vanquished the Packers, 31-24, in Super Bowl XXXII in San Diego.
When he was asked if the 1997 season Super Bowl was the highlight of his playing career, Romanowski didn't say a word.
He just held up his hand with the Super Bowl ring on it.
