If Payton Manning gets a second ring this year , is he the best ever ?

[Railbird]

Marino much better.

 

[Boxer22]

Marino much better.

Marino much better then Manning?

 

[Boxer22]

Pressure Peyton thru the A gap and guard Clark and he aint shit. He will fail in January just like always.

Last time I checked Manning has a ring and Marino doesn't.

 

[5teamparlay]

Maybe best passer, can't run all that well, not that he needs to......

 

[5teamparlay]

Last time I checked Manning has a ring and Marino doesn't.

Aikman has 3 ....... nowhere on any top QB lists...

 

[TomGshotput]

Last time I checked 2 is less then 3 or 4.

When I checked, one was less than 22. . .

 

[GoSooners]

I think the posters on here who are calling Manning the best ever are probably the under 40 set who hasn't seen the "other generation" of pro football players play. You know, the generation who didn't have the plays coming in through their helmets.

 

[billhill999]

Bart Starr won 3 NFL Championships before the inception of the Super Bowl.
He then went on to win the first two Super Bowls, for a total of five NFL Championships.

Talk to me when Peyton wins at least two more.

 

[Samhain]

Rings aren't significant.

Trent Dilfer has a ring. He's not better than Dan Fouts.
Jim McMahon has two rings. He's not better than Dan Marino.

 

[DesertDevil]

Rings aren't significant.

Trent Dilfer has a ring. He's not better than Dan Fouts.
Jim McMahon has two rings. He's not better than Dan Marino.

Well, they are significant, but I agree with your point.

Rings are the most overated stat when comparing the best QB's of all time in my opinion.

People fail to realize that 52 other people make up NFL rosters. Although the QB position might be the most valuable of all, too many other factors can cause a QB to never reach championship status. Despite how good they might be.

 

[billhill999]

Would the Packers have won 5 Championships with a different QB than Starr?

 

[bucsfan67]

I believe Manning is the best ever already.

agreed...as far as overall, arm, strength, mental acuity, he is the total package.....if he was mobile at all it wouldnt even be close, that is his ONLY fault...

but i agree, he is the best there has been......

 

[bucsfan67]

Pressure Peyton thru the A gap and guard Clark and he aint shit. He will fail in January just like always.

you sure pegged that one....Peyton AIN'T shit...

 

[DesertDevil]

Would the Packers have won 5 Championships with a different QB than Starr?

Impossible to tell. Probably not.

But could they have won 3 or 4?

They obviously had great teams to go along with a great QB to win 5 titles.