If Ohio State....

[Defying]

If Ohio State never lost to Virginia Tech and was undefeated right now....

But lost Both Braxton and JT ... Should they be in the Playoffs?

Edit: If they Lose to Wisconsin this week...

 

[PatsFanatic]

Yes

 

[MikeB]

Definitely

 

[slapshot]

No

 

[packer2012]

The question really is not "should they be in?" They would be absolutely. Urban has enough butt lickers around the country the committee would feel pressure.... as they do already, I'm sure.

 

[packer2012]

Don't hear much conversation about.... Why did they require the one team (non big 5 conference)to be included in the big bowls.

Of course the answer is..... people don't have enough balls to do what they should do.

 

[ALSportsJunkie]

If they beat Wisconsin they deserve to be in QB or not.

 

[Defying]

If they beat Wisconsin they deserve to be in QB or not.

what if they lose?

They said from the start that injuries play in the decision making

 

[NickPappagiorgio]

If they beat Wisconsin they deserve to be in QB or not.

No they dont, not unless both TCU and Baylor lose a game. You cant lose to Va Tech at home and be part of the conversation.

 

[Defying]

No they dont, not unless both TCU and Baylor lose a game. You cant lose to Va Tech at home and be part of the conversation.

think he was answering the question if OSU was undefeated

 

[NickPappagiorgio]

think he was answering the question if OSU was undefeated

I didnt read it that way, but if he did mean that i apologize

 

[ALSportsJunkie]

what if they lose?

They said from the start that injuries play in the decision making

Well, if they lose it is simple - they are out.

I don't really agree with the whole injury thing. If FSU gets by Georgia Tech but on some fluke play Jameis tears his ACL at the end of the game they could leave them out? I just don't see how you could look the public in the eye and say "hey, your good enough but your QB is hurt so all of you guys can pack it up - season is over" that is bullshit IMO.

 

[ALSportsJunkie]

No they dont, not unless both TCU and Baylor lose a game. You cant lose to Va Tech at home and be part of the conversation.

I am not sure. I think we could make an argument for any of those three to be the last team in. I do think the committee will choose Ohio State based on the conference championship regardless. B12 needs to get with program and get a championship game of some kind.

 

[RenoChazz]

I want to see 8 teams make the play offs.

 

[CoachCB]

No

 

[MikeB]

I want to see 8 teams make the play offs.

At least 8

I'd be OK with doing what the NFL does too. Give a bye week and expand it.

 

[5teamparlay]

if ohio state never lost to virginia tech and was undefeated right now....

But lost both braxton and jt ... Should they be in the playoffs?

Edit: If they lose to wisconsin this week...

braxton who??