If Eli Manning Flops later on, Would He Be The Biggest Bust In NFL History?

[HacheMan]

In your opinion, if Eli Manning Flops, Would He Be The Biggest Bust In NFL History? Of course, there are many players that are worthy of that title,such as Tony Mandarich, Heath Shuler, Blair Thomas and more , but with the expectations riding on this guy, surely he would be the biggest of all..........

 

[Journeyman]

Biggest or LARGEST? ...Tony Madarich comes to mind immediately Hache LOL

 

[TheGeneral+]

Ryan Leaf comes to mind.

 

[Cujo]

Personally, I think Ryan Leaf should have that title. He was trouble on and off the field.

 

[DavidMatthews]

Ryan Leaf must rank up there a bit (pun intended)

 

[DavidMatthews]

Wow. 3 people posting Leaf all at once.

 

[HacheMan]

I agree with Ryan Leaf, I thought about him also, but I don't think even what was expected of him can compare to that of Peyton's little bro......

 

[Journeyman]

Well Leaf was compared to Manning who is as good passer as the game has....So I would say that comparison was a bit off....Shuler was another 'never was'....

How about some of the Penn State RBs Carter, and Enis and Blair Thomas...Larry Johnson may be the next big bust from Joe Pa's stable...

 

[HacheMan]

Talk down this way J~Man was that there have been some discussions between Tampa Bay and Kansas City in swapping Keenan McCArdell for Larry Johsnon. If that's that case, and KC is willing to part with such a young player already, maybe they suspect something similar to what you stated above, that he may be a bust.......

 

[Journeyman]

All the Penn State backs looks so good in college too Hache...Just destroying defenses... Enis was unstoppable....I heard he was a serious pot head though.

 

[HacheMan]

I don't really think KiJana Carter should be included in such a group, simply because an injury kept him from showing the world what he can do. You have to give him much respect to still come back from that knee problem today....

 

[5teamparlay]

Guy won 2 SBs


good luck tonight

but it may be over



pahe 3075 bump

 

[Greenbacks]

Good bump

As a fan he won me 2 Super bowls.

He is washed up now.

But he had a solid career