I think I just moved RG3 above Luck on my big board

[CHOPTALK]

My God they are both awesome.

How do you separate the two?

Flip a fricken coin.

 

[RoofTop]

If Vince Young had this guys head on his shoulders....what could've been

 

[silver7]

See me in 10 yrs LOL, Luck will be All Pro, ala Vick, R2D2 will be day to day.. Way too many hits and he's not a big guy. Look at Big Ben w/his sz & style, he's on the bench too many games.

 

[trytrytry]

RG3 the story of the year in the NFC...

 

[Murphy8276]

My God they are both awesome.

How do you separate the two?

Flip a fricken coin.

seriously bro...

do u really have ur own big board? puff_>>

-murph

 

[JustinCruise]

You can't go wrong with either guy, and right now it is WAY to early to start making comparisons. Imagine if people judged Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers in their first season.

I have luck slightly ahead for the simple fact that I see RG3 as a big injury risk. Both guys are special.

 

[PimpyMcPimp]

I have luck slightly ahead for the simple fact that I see RG3 as a big injury risk. Both guys are special.

I agree. With his style of play RG3 takes some nasty hits.

 

[Mr_Mark]

Both guys are probably top 10 QBs

 

[Stax]

I agree. With his style of play RG3 takes some nasty hits.

Yes. He has taken some beatings. He won't last if it doesn't get better protection.

 

[Murphy8276]

Yes. He has taken some beatings. He won't last if it doesn't get better protection.

at least he is elusive enough to avoid some of them.. heck he runs right into the defenders though.. guy is fearless !/

-murph

 

[Defying]

I guess I am the only one not sold on Luck..... low completion percentage 55.5% which by the way is rather bad.....

I know his yardage is impressive but they are throwing it 42 times a game... he better have some good yardage... I don't know, im just not sold on the guy yet

 

[JustinCruise]

I guess I am the only one not sold on Luck..... low completion percentage 55.5% which by the way is rather bad.....

I know his yardage is impressive but they are throwing it 42 times a game... he better have some good yardage... I don't know, im just not sold on the guy yet

You are.