Has Kurt Warner had a better career than Peyton Manning?

[Railbird]

Absoutely.

His playoff winning percentage is heaps better, I would rather have Kurt behind center for my money anyday.

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

It just never ends.....please tells us how Rail, this ought to be good...

 

[RobFunk]

If Peyton loses tonight, I will agree with you. Fair enough?

 

[BEANTOWNJIM]

RAILBIRD I THINK YOU HAVE BEEN PLAYING TO MANY GAMES OF CHECKERS WITH YOUR MOTHER INSTEAD OF WATCHING FOOTBALL.YOU HAVE SAID SOME CRAZY STUFF BUT THIS MIGHT HAVE BEEN THE MOST UNINTELLIGENT.

RAILBIRD I THINK MOM WANTS A RE MATCH IN THE CHECKERS SO DONT WATCH PEYTON TONIGHT GO PLAY CHECKERS WITH MA.

WOW THIS IS A STRANGE THREAD.KURT WARNER IS A LOSER

 

[FairWarning]

Warner is from Iowa which is closer to the west coast than growing up in Mississippi.

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

RAILBIRD I THINK YOU HAVE BEEN PLAYING TO MANY GAMES OF CHECKERS WITH YOUR MOTHER INSTEAD OF WATCHING FOOTBALL.YOU HAVE SAID SOME CRAZY STUFF BUT THIS MIGHT HAVE BEEN THE MOST UNINTELLIGENT.

RAILBIRD I THINK MOM WANTS A RE MATCH IN THE CHECKERS SO DONT WATCH PEYTON TONIGHT GO PLAY CHECKERS WITH MA.

WOW THIS IS A STRANGE THREAD.KURT WARNER IS A LOSER

It is scrabble....

 

[RobFunk]

Peyton Manning in the playoffs 7-7, 1 championship

Kurt Warner in the playoffs (as of now) 6-2, 1 championship

http://www.pro-football-reference.com

 

[RobFunk]

Warner is from Iowa which is closer to the west coast than growing up in Mississippi.

:lolBIG:

That's definatly it. Thanks for pointing that out.

 

[shdw01]

i will agree that kurt warner has had a better playoff career.....however:

1) Peyton should have more years left than kurt so time will tell how their respective careers end.
2) Peyton has had a better regular season career than Warner.
3) I will take Peyton Manning anyday over warner if they both have the same supporting cast.

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

Peyton Manning in the playoffs 7-7, 1 championship

Kurt Warner in the playoffs (as of now) 6-2, 1 championship

http://www.pro-football-reference.com

Please Funk, I thought you were smarter than this...if you go by this, I will take Trent Dilfer for my money...:missingte

 

[RobFunk]

Please Funk, I thought you were smarter than this...if you go by this, I will take Trent Dilfer for my money...:missingte

No, no, not going by it. Just posting it. Because when Rail said "His playoff winning percentage is heaps better" I had to check it out. So I figured I'd share.

Peyton has been to the playoffs more often so that is a check in his favor.

 

[Railbird]

I want to know how many ints Manning threw in those 7 playoff losses? Its got to be well into the 20's.

throw out the 1 year where Manning hid behind his defense and runningback and he is 3-7.

 

[RobFunk]

I want to know how many ints Manning threw in those 7 playoff losses? Its got to be well into the 20's.

throw out the 1 year where Manning hid behind his defense and runningback and he is 3-7.

Peyton in the playoffs 21 TD 17 INT, 84.4 rate

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/M/MannPe00_playoffs.htm

 

[FairWarning]

Manning 6-6 81 yards on the scoring drive, but hid behind the Addai TD run.

 

[Gaz]

Peyton Manning in the playoffs 7-7, 1 championship

Kurt Warner in the playoffs (as of now) 6-2, 1 championship

http://www.pro-football-reference.com

Nice cherry picking stats, how about posting up career wins and losses?

 

[RobFunk]

Nice cherry picking stats, how about posting up career wins and losses?

It's not like that. He mentioned the playoffs, so that is what I dug up out of curiousity. (see post #11)

 

[Boxer22]

Peyton Manning in the playoffs 7-7, 1 championship

Kurt Warner in the playoffs (as of now) 6-2, 1 championship

http://www.pro-football-reference.com

What a joke.

 

[Seymour]

Same story - yawn - them aliens coming soon?

 

[D2bets]

176 games for Manning to 110 games for Warner. Hard to even compare. Came into the league the same year and Manning has NEVER missed a start. That alone puts him ahead. Warner got to ride the bench while he wasn't good enough to start.

No freaking comparison, regardless what happens today. Plus Manning has consistently had tougher competition in the AFC.

 

[nimue77]

The better question is....are you insane?!?!

Absoutely.

His playoff winning percentage is heaps better, I would rather have Kurt behind center for my money anyday.