loved the book, liked the movie. highlighted some of the wrong characters and felt like they just jammed marisa tomei in there to have a female presence despite adding nothing to the actual move (or book).
could have been a fantastic film but was only good, not great. saw lewis interviewed and he said they did a very good job with the character development and makeup (bale and carrell in particular looked and acted exactly like the real guys) but seemed to be, like me, a little lukewarm on the overall movie. I loved how Moneyball stayed true to the book and highlighted Pitt's character's personal life without taking away from the story...here, it just sort of jumped all over the place and you never knew what character would get highlighted next where the book flowed really well despite telling 4 different stories
my wife didn't read the book and loved the movie so it was probably my heightened expectations that sour me a bit