Has any major pro athlete ever won both Rookie of the year and league MVP? (Same Season)

[RenoChazz 0]

US Hockey phenom from Arizona (yes Arizona) Austin Matthews is in that conversation. He's a shoo in for Rookie of the year, and probably a close second to Crosby for MVP. If you go by most valuable to their team, I'm giving it to Matthews. Toronto went from last, to a play off team in one year, which is rare in Hockey. Crosby's rookie year Penguins were last again.

Anyone think Austin has a shot at MVP?

 

[stale 0]

Didn't Fred Lynn?

 

[CHOPTALK 0]

Earl Campbell

 

[slapshot 0]

nope think McDavid will get MVP

crazy both the Oil 70 and Leafs 69 points last year down to the wire for last place

heading into the final week Oil 1st in the Pacific and Leafs 2nd in the Atlantic

 

[RenoChazz 0]

Earl Campbell

Was it the same season? Thought his MVP was sophmore year?

 

[RenoChazz 0]

nope think McDavid will get MVP

crazy both the Oil 70 and Leafs 69 points last year down to the wire for last place

heading into the final week Oil 1st in the Pacific and Leafs 2nd in the Atlantic

The difference is Oilers sucked Mcdavid's first year. He's got experience and more top draft picks playing with him.

 

[MikeyLo 0]

Ichiro 2001?

 

[niltes 0]

fernando won cy young and ROY in 81 i believe

 

[mango 0]

Wilt and Wes Unseld.

 

[festeringZit 0]

Ichiro and Fred Lynn only baseball players to do it...

 

[slapshot 0]

Matthews is tied with Sid for the lead in even strength goals at 30

 

[rolltide 0]

matthews won't finish in top 5 for the Hart. his over/under for order of finish is probably 8.5

 

[Ricboff 0]

and the nominees are.......(or rather mine....)............


1. Brad Marchaud - Boston

having a career year, finishing strong .....leading his team into the playoffs. Kinda guy you'd love to have on your team, but hate the fucker if opposing. The guy is ALL heart. He has supplanted Brent Burns who was making a legit run for MVP until fallign off the map, as have the Sharks

2. Sidney Crosby- Pittsburgh

possibly could have won the scoring title if hadn't missed a few games. Leads the league with 43 goals.....the consummate Captain.

3. Connor McDavid- Edmonton Oilers
chap given the 'C' to start the year--The Oilers are headed to the playoffs. Art Ross is in the bag.......

..........and the winner is..............

the kid as a Marlboro....................



............


Austin has no chance. Heck of a player, loves to park himself in front of the net-what of a release! Brown/Hyman do the dirty work in the corners

Marner
Mathews
Nylander


are you kidding me?.............