Dave Malinsky
Today’s Free Pick
Cincinnati Reds @ New York Mets Jul 10, 2009 7:10PM
PICK: over
REASON FOR PICK: 4* #956 NY METS/CINCINNATI Over
Struggling starters and tired bullpens are hardly the recipe for a pitcher’s duel, and that is why we were so surprised to find the 9’s left open as “win” numbers for this one. In a game in which there will be a vulnerable pitcher on the mound in every inning except for perhaps the 9th, asking each team to scratch out four runs does not make us beggars.
We are not sure that Bronson Arroyo should be pitching right now. A bout with carpal tunnel syndrome has turned his season into a mess, and the Reds have already stated the off-season surgery is in the cards. So why wait? Although cortisone shots have eased the pain a bit his game is a disaster right now, with an 0-3/10.29 over his last three starts that has actually been even worse than those baseline numbers. He allowed six home runs in only 14 innings in that span, with far more walks (9) than strikeouts (6), and a stratospheric 2.71 WHIP does not fully translate to the ERA column because there were a couple of unearned tallies that do not show up. There just is not any reason to believe that he turns around here, and with the Cincinnati starters only lasting 22 innings over the last five games a tired bullpen may reach overload. This will also be the second look for the Mets at him this season, and Arroyo has worked to an awful 8.85 over four second-look outings so far.
Fernando Nieve’s 3-2/2.73 helps to bring a low price here but that is not who he is. Like many call-ups he had an adrenaline rush through a few starts, which led to a couple of solid performances, but now that has worn off, and opposing teams also have scouting reports. As such he has lasted only nine innings over his last two starts, allowing six runs on 17 hits, with an ugly ratio of seven walks vs. only four strikeouts, and you can see part of where this bargain line comes from in that distribution – if you allow 17 hits and seven walks over nine frames, but only six runs scored, you have cashed a lottery ticket. Nieve is not a candidate to go deeply into a game even when his limited stuff is on, and that is bad news for the Met bullpen, after the starters could only generate 12 of the 27 innings in the series vs. the Dodgers.
4* NY METS/CINCINNATI Over