FANTASY Question: Manning or Mariota?

varkeyboy · Sep 17, 2015

In my big league, I picked up Manning. Obviously, i wasn't satisfied w/ his week 1 performance. Although, i still won because i have a well balance team (Lacy, Forsett, B Marshall, Hopkins, Garcon, Cameron, Miami D)......

Anyways, I need some help.......

I just picked up Mariota off waivers........

WHO WOULD YOU START? Manning or Mariota........and WHY??? Thanks fellas.

PigskinArmor · Sep 17, 2015

Mariota nothing to lose, Manning has everything to lose. Choose wisely.

cclow1 · Sep 17, 2015

Its hard to sit Manning. I have him as well and was not happy with week 1 but did pull a W. Too early to give up on him. Roll with the vet

varkeyboy · Sep 17, 2015

cclow1 said:
Its hard to sit Manning. I have him as well and was not happy with week 1 but did pull a W. Too early to give up on him. Roll with the vet

What i was thinking my friend.........so hard for me to bench him.

Slurve~Ball · Sep 17, 2015

CLE defense is big step up from TBs. Will not be surprised if TEN at CLE turns into a FG fest.

KC secondary not all it's cracked up to be. See how many yards Hoyer and Mallet put up last week. Sean Smith suspension hurting KC.

Mixerdriver76 · Sep 17, 2015

I don't play fantasy but I do know the Manning has faced kc something like 13 times and won all but 1 time

Vols2009 · Sep 17, 2015

So hard to bench Manning. I'd go with him another week to see how he really is. Two bad games in a row might lead me to bench him

varkeyboy · Sep 17, 2015

Vols2009 said:
So hard to bench Manning. I'd go with him another week to see how he really is. Two bad games in a row might lead me to bench him

Good advice my friend. I'll play Manning tonight. Why not? Gotta trust the guy....esp w/ all the crap the media's been talking about him. Hopefully get a nice, solid game out of him. I'm just asking for 15-25 points....not being greedy. LOL!

Thanks for your input fellas.