ESPN Top 10 QB's

[TheGeneral+]

#10 Pennington, #9 Culpepper, #8 Vick, #7 Green, #6 Hassleback, #5 McNabb, #4 Favre, #3 McNair, #2 T Brady, #1 Peyton Manning

 

[oldmanTED]

Candidly, this list shows just how weak the NFL has become at quarterback. Other then Favre, Manning and possibly Brady, the rest are the best of an average field in the league. The days of Montana, Marino, Elway, Young, to name a few, are sadly, long gone. Parity in the NFL has creeped into all positions. Still love the game, but the quality of play is not what it was just a few years ago.

 

[Journeyman]

No doubt, and I have said this before the position is in sad shape overall....look at the position 10-15 years ago compared to now....The league can't even fill each team with a quality QB...just look at Dallas ...

 

[JudgeWapner]

I think Pennington is gonna be something special.

 

[trytrytry]

how is Tom Brady not on this list alone and then the next 2-10 listed????

 

[Railbird]

Manning sucks, Pennington is horrendous. I have no respect for anybodys opinion here.

 

[Journeyman]

My top 5

McNair does more with less
Favre still the man
Brady proven winner
Manning hasn't won enough
McNabb at #5 just shows how far the QB position has dropped off
Pennington huge upside
Green

 

[BeatTheBookies]

Manning
McNair
Culpepper
Green
Brady

 

[JudgeWapner]

Rail and the feeling is mutual.I know,you think Flutie is the best QB in the NFL.Which shows your vast knowledge of football.

 

[Railbird]

Tons of folks I have never heard of beg me for plays, my opinion is superior.

 

[Railbird]

my opinion is Pennington is not very good

 

[JudgeWapner]

Of course.Which is why you have to scalp tickets to make a living.

 

[blueedwards]

come on judge...you are just saying that because he puts khalil green above a-rod and honus wagner on the all-time shortstop list.

 

[Railbird]

I havent retailed a ticket in over a year, because I win for a living. I play golf and tennis all day

 

[JudgeWapner]

Uh huh.

 

[blueedwards]

hey rail, how is jj gold doing. man, i miss that guy.

 

[oldmanTED]

Rail:

So anything you like in the Buick Open today?

 

[VaultedTreehouse]

Pennington is better than #10. I'm shocked at the people saying he's awful. I'm at every game and he is much better than you think. This is only his 2nd full year at starter and his first was one of the best years at QB that year. A bunch of haters in here.

 

[JudgeWapner]

VT,agreed.

 

[DrunkenHorseplayer]

Brady is like Montana; damn good but, thanks to a great supporting cast on both sides of the ball, over-rated.

1) Manning
2) Favre
3) Vick
4) McNabb
5) Pennington

With an injury-free season Vick could end up number one on my list. He looks like he could be another Elway; a guy who can turn a defense's biggest asset (a brutal pss-rush) into a liability.