Does this list of all time greatest 10 QB's of all time suck or what?

[CHOPTALK]

http://wallstcheatsheet.com/sports/the-10-greatest-nfl-quarterbacks-of-all-time.html/11/?ref=OB

1. Joe Montana
2. John Elway
3. Dan Marino
4. Tom Brady
5. Brett Favre
6. Johnny Unitas
7. Peyton Manning
8. Steve Young
9. Otto Graham
10. Fran Tarkenton

I mean the greatest QB of all-time is not even in the top 10.
Peyton Manning 7. LOL
Marino and Elway ahead of Brady?

 

[Shub]

Maybe it's strongest arm

 

[ANOTHERDAY]

Marino was the purest of all by far....If his era had the rules of today, he would have thrown 60+ td's and 6000 yrds easy for a few seasons.

Everyone knew what he was going to do and he still did it. Brady, Farve, and Manning lived off of the rules, not to mention screens and dumpoffs (just the new era).

Not to mention, protection (Marino had none)

 

[JustinCruise]

Favre at 5 is ABSURD. He shouldn't be on the list at all

 

[cy1981]

Maybe it's strongest arm

Strongest arm and Montana wouldn't be in the top 100.

 

[Betallsports]

Hmm, wonder who you think is the "Greatest" QB of all time .. That's not on the list :think2:

 

[cy1981]

I would take Elway at number 1. If all these QBs played at the same time every team would have traded their QB even up for Elway. Arm, legs, and a winner.

 

[festeringZit]

Marino was the purest of all by far....If his era had the rules of today, he would have thrown 60+ td's and 6000 yrds easy for a few seasons.

Everyone knew what he was going to do and he still did it. Brady, Farve, and Manning lived off of the rules, not to mention screens and dumpoffs (just the new era).

Not to mention, protection (Marino had none)

^<<^hno:

 

[NickPappagiorgio]

Favre at 5 is ABSURD. He shouldn't be on the list at all

Favre in his prime was as good as anyone

 

[HacheMan]

Favre in his prime was as good as anyone

I agree

Ask Hall Of Famers Warren Sapp & Derrick Brooks & they'll tell you the same...

 

[Shub]

Favre at 5 is ABSURD. He shouldn't be on the list at all

He played like 200 something's games in a row....

 

[Betallsports]

Hmm, wonder who you think is the "Greatest" QB of all time .. That's not on the list :think2:

Waiting on a reply

 

[HacheMan]

Chop's talking about Drew Brees.

And he's probably right, he does belong in the top 10.

Brees & Manning are the only star QB's who have shown they can still dominate when transferring to a different team.

We'll never know that about most of the others...

 

[Defying]

Chop's talking about Drew Brees.

And he's probably right, he does belong in the top 10.

Trees & Manning are the only star QB's who have shown they can still dominate when transferring to a different team.

We'll never know that about most of the others...

Brees isn't in my top 10 of all time....

 

[HacheMan]

Brees isn't in my top 10 of all time....

He would be in mine, and easily over Tarkenton & Graham...

 

[DrunkenHorseplayer]

Montana and Brady had talent that simply couldn't lose; Tarkenton should be higher on the list.

 

[Acebb]

Drew Brees top 10 of all time?

LMFAO.

 

[loomis41973]

I think it's pretty good....maybe drop Marino a spot or two.


Leaving out Brees is a no brainer.

 

[Seymour]

Manning, Marino, Brady, Montana and Elway is the top 5 and there's little difference among those 5 in terms of success

 

[Willie99]

Chop's talking about Drew Brees.

And he's probably right, he does belong in the top 10.

Brees & Manning are the only star QB's who have shown they can still dominate when transferring to a different team.

We'll never know that about most of the others...

Some have superstars surrounding them their entire career, some play with the same personnel for a decade, some play in one system most of their careers, while others start new every couple of years

I would suggest we may never know how the league's most pampered QBs would perform with constant turnover around them while throwing to a very average crop of receivers