Best ever my a@@, MOST OVERRATED ever is more like it. SoccerBob, you said it best, this guy disappeared in the crucial situations. I am so tired about hearing how if he had a great offensive line he would have been even greater than he was. How can the greatest ever be pulled in the most crucial times of the possesion down at the goal line? Amazing how when Barry broke one for a big gain all you heard about was what a great back he is, but when he got caught 5 yards behind the line of scrimmage the other 9 carries, the offensive line sucked.
Now dont get me wrong, Barry was a good running back, but not the greatest ever, Top 3 to 5 definitely, but not the greatest ever.
40 years from now people will still be calling him the greatest back ever because all they will see is the numbers which are impressive, but you have to look at how those numbers were arrived at.
How one arrives at who was the best at thier position is a matter of opinion, I just dont think Barry should be classified as the best ever at his position IMO. Makes for a great bar room discussion though.
I never saw Brown or Sayers play but did see Walter Payton play and to say Barry was better than Payton is an insult to "Sweetness". Compare the 2 offensive lines of Chicago and Detroit and you will find that neither line was probably in the top 100 of all time in the NFL. Payton could do much more than Barry could and to this day I think Mike Ditka is the biggest a$$ clown out thier for not giving Payton the chance to score in the Super Bowl debacle over New England. By allowing the fat #$@! William Perry to score was an insult not only to Payton but to the game of football.
My vote for the greatest ever would be Walter Payton!!!