I watched the first 45 minutes of it last night. It's watchable I guess.
Typical reality tv show though. As in not all that much reality. Definitely some scripted parts. The one girl "secretly" being pregnant is super obvious. And for all the time the narrator spent talking about how little rations they now had, the producers sure seemed to have given them plenty of booze.
I plan on watching the rest of the episode.
I agree with you though. Great concept. But I'm afraid they ruined the concept by overproducing it/ensuring drama. Pretty obvious that religion/no religion is going to be a Major focal point of the series.