Umm... Lets break this down:
Catcher: Varitek has been horrid this season at the plate, Napoli has been excellent in the second half in a platoon with Mathis, but I'm not sure you can definitively give the advantage to the Angels given Varitek's defensive capabilities/his ability as a battery mate, not to mention his postseason experience.
Even.
First base: Jordan and the idiots who follow him will call me crazy, but you simply cannot make the argument that Teixeira is better than Youkilis. Youkilis is a better defender than Teixeira (and thats saying something considering how good Tex is defensively), they're OPS's were .004 apart and all of their other numbers are almost identical.
Even.
Second base: Kendrick is a very solid player, but unlike Pedroia, Kendrick has zero power and it reflects with Pedroia having an OPS over .100 points higher. Pedroia is in the MVP running, the batting title running and is just simply the better player.
Red Sox.
Short Stop: Both Aybar and Lowrie have better days ahead of them, but at this point in their career, Jed Lowrie is the better player.
Red Sox.
Third Base: Either way you look at it, if Youkilis switches over to third or Lowell is able to play, the Red Sox have the far superior third baseman. Nonetheless, given the uncertainty of this position for the Red Sox with the injury to Lowell, I'll give the Angels the benefit of the doubt and call it even.
Even.
Leftfield: There is not even a question here. Jason Bay is a far superior player right now than Garret Anderson is. He's better defensively, he gets on base at a way higher clip, he hits for more power. The Anderson of five years ago would have allowed us to debate these two, but at this point in their respective careers, Jason Bay is a better player.
Red Sox.
Centerfield: Ellsbury has been disappointing this year, Crisp has been disappointing since his arrival in Boston a couple of years ago. Mark Kotsay is another option, but it doesn't matter, Torii Hunter a better player than all three (although Ellsbury will be excellent down the road).
Angels.
Rightfield: Gary Matthews Jr. is a bad baseball player. You place him in the corner and take away his defensive prowess and he becomes a completely useless player. J.D. Drew, Ellsbury, Kotsay or whomever the Red Sox throw out in right will be more productive than Sarge Jr.
DH: David Ortiz versus Vladimir Guerrero. Possibly the hardest to debate, so I'm going to take the easy road and just call it even. At first glance, Guerrero has the better numbers, but their OPS's are almost identical and the lack of total numbers on the part of Papi are moreso to do with being injured than anything else.
Even.
In total: The Angels only advantage amongst position players is in centerfield, but the drop off from Hunter to Ellsbury/Crisp/Kotsay really doesn't scare me into throwing the house on the Angels in this series. The Red Sox have clear cut advantages at second base and left field and a slight advantage at short.
On the pitching end, the Red Sox have the better rotation and a bullpen that is just as good if not better than the Angels.
In tonights match up: Lackey has been a shell of his former self in the second half while Jon Lester has been good enough to put himself in the Cy Young running.
Obviously, the Angels are favored because they won the most games (in the worst division in baseball), but saying the Red Sox have no chance tonight or in this series is just downright silly.