Who do you take with the #1 pick in a fantasy draft.
LT2 is obviously more proven, but I think he's getting older and he seems to be in a decline.
Adrian Peterson is young, but very explosive.
I'd go AP, I like the risk/reward better.
LaDanian Tomlinson is the most dominant fantasy player in the game. True, his numbers did decline last year but when you run for 1,815 yards, 28 touchdowns and catch 58 balls for 503 yards with 3 more touchdowns it is pretty hard to live up to the hype.
Given that LDT ran for totals of 25, 43, and 62 yards in his first 3 games for just one touchdown. Those first 3 games he went against some very strong fronts like the Bears, Patriots, and Packers. So with those numbers its pretty impressive that he still ran for 1474 yards and 15 touchdowns.
Adrian Peterson is great and should be a very good NFL back but, lets not forget it has been only one year. The problem with Adrian Peterson is his inconsistency to play every game the same. I feel like if he gets off to a strong start he will continue to play very well but if he gets off to a tough start he is going to get frustrated and slow it down a bit. Peterson had weeks where he single handedly won fantasy owners game and single handedly lost them. He only had touchdowns in 7 games and only ran for 100 yards 6 times. Granted one time he ran for 296 yards and 3 scores and 224 yards and 3 scores but thats not what you want out of a #1 pick. You want a guy who will win you games and will rarely kill you.
LaDanian Tomlinson #1 overall.