I don't think anyone doubts that this team has the weapons to score a lot of goals, especially with Stamkos joining the team this season, but they still have no defense. I love Smith as a goalie and I think he is a franchise goaltender, but that means nothing if you have no defense to protect him.
Kolzig was highly overpayed when you look at his talent and what he can do for you between the pipes right now, but he will be a great guy for Smith to learn from in practice which makes it a good signing IMO. This team is a question mark to me. They could either make the playoffs in an extremely weak division, or they could finish near the bottom again, which would be good for them so they can pick up a top defensemen next year in the draft.