Philippines to Withdraw Forces from Iraq

Search

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,398
Tokens
Manila Says it Will Withdraw from Iraq

Philippines to comply with captors’ demands ‘as soon as possible’

040710_newhostage_hmed_7a.hmedium.jpg

Philippine hostage Angelo dela Cruz begs his government to withdraw troops from Iraq in a video shown Saturday on Al-Jazeera.

(MSNBC)

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates - Facing a deadline set by militants to behead a Philippine hostage, the Philippines said Monday that it would withdraw its forces from Iraq “as soon as possible.”

In a statement he read on the Arab-language news channel Al-Jazeera, Deputy Foreign Minister Rafael Seguis said his country’s “humanitarian forces” would be pulled “in response to your request.”

The deadline for the execution of the hostage, Angelo dela Cruz, 46, a truck driver, passed in silence at 3 a.m. Tuesday in his home village (3 p.m. ET Monday) as family and friends exhausted by days of uncertainty slept.

Al-Jazeera broadcast a videotape earlier Monday in which the militant group, the Iraqi Islamic Army-Khaled bin Al-Waleed Corps, said dela Cruz had been taken to the place where he would be killed if the Philippines failed to agree to pull its troops from Iraq by July 20. It said its had done everything in its power to prove that it wanted to spare his life.

Dela Cruz was shown pleading for his life in the new video, in which he asked that his body be sent to the Philippines for burial should he be killed. He was wearing an orange garment similar to those worn by two other hostages who have been beheaded: U.S. businessman Nicholas Berg and South Korean translator Kim Sun-il.

Confusion Over Deadline

The group originally had said it would kill dela Cruz by Sunday if the Philippines did not comply. The Philippines government said Monday morning that the group had extended the deadline by 48 hours, until 3 p.m. ET Tuesday, but in its new videotape and statement, the group said it was extending the deadline for only 24 hours.

Up until Seguis announced his government’s compliance, the Philippines had rejected the demand and said its 51 soldiers and police would leave Aug. 20, as scheduled.

U.S. Ambassador Francis Ricciardone expressed support for President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo’s efforts to obtain the hostage’s release while remaining one of Washington’s closest supporters in the war on terrorism.

“She’s shown a deep, deep care for this hostage but also careful of the country’s long-term interests,” he said on ABS-CBN TV.

040709_hostages_filipino_bcol_4a.standard.jpg

A protester shouts anti-government slogans last week during a rally outside the Foreign Affairs Department in Manila.

The drama has prompted prayer vigils throughout the sprawling Philippine archipelago. On a Manila street, taxi drivers lit candles on a roadside and prayed for dela Cruz. Television and radio stations in the predominantly Roman Catholic country broadcast appeals by Muslim and Christian leaders for his release.

A senior government official told The Associated Press on condition of anonymity that dela Cruz may now be in custody of another cell of the same group of militants that seized him.

He said government negotiators were trying to contact the kidnappers through intermediaries, including Pakistani officials in Baghdad who had secured the release of one of their citizens.

Hope for Bulgarian Captives

Iraqi militants have repeatedly used terrorist attacks to try to force governments to withdraw from the U.S.-led occupation force.

In March, a series of terrorist bombings on commuter trains in Madrid shortly before national elections was believed to have contributed to a victory by the socialists, who had campaigned on a platform of withdrawing Spanish troops from Iraq. The new prime minister, Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, pulled out the troops soon after taking office.

Militants also tried to pressure South Korea by kidnapping Kim in Iraq and demanding that Seoul drop plans to deploy 3,000 troops beginning in August. South Korea refused, and Kim was beheaded last month.

Bulgaria said, meanwhile, that it was still confident that two of its nationals were alive despite the passing of an execution deadline Friday.

“We ... have enough operational data which show that the two are alive and that the captors are receiving our messages through the Arabic satellite television Al Jazeera and the Bulgarian media,” Defense Minister Nikolai Svinarov said.

Kidnappers threatened to kill the Bulgarians within 24 hours unless the United States freed Iraqi prisoners.

President Bush spoke Sunday with Bulgarian President Georgi Parvanov and received reassurances that Bulgaria’s troop commitment in the country remained strong despite the threats. Bush offered to assist but refused to negotiate with terrorists, the White House said.

Bulgaria has a 480-member infantry unit in Iraq that is under Polish command in the city of Karbala. Its main duties are patrolling the center of the city and guarding public buildings.

Five Bulgarian soldiers died in a suicide attack against their base in December. In April, a sixth Bulgarian was killed in a skirmish with insurgents.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,228
Tokens
Thats pretty cool.(if true)

Their people were there for humanitarian stuff anyway.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 25, 2000
Messages
4,257
Tokens
If the Philippines pull out it shouldn't take long, just get all four of them back in the humvee and head out...
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
1,245
Tokens
Now that this kidnapping worked out so well, which other country will be next? The kidnappers should have thrown in a monetary demand as well, maybe $10 million plus 15 O.J. Simpson rookie cards, to further their terrorist actions. The Filipinos probably would have given it to them.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 25, 2000
Messages
4,257
Tokens
American....you know, with all the beheadings going on, maybe someone should call up O.J. so he can quit looking for the real killers....

....pretty obvious they are somewhere in the middle east....just need some forensic evidence that puts them at the crime scene in California...
 

New member
Joined
Oct 20, 2002
Messages
886
Tokens
Isn't blackmail great ? Wow ..every country will become wussies !!!!!
 

There's always next year, like in 75, 90-93, 99 &
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
15,270
Tokens
American,
You write like a modern day rambo ...
why aren't you over there freeing captives instead of tough guy posting?

Oh, reality TV isn't fun when it's your own reality
icon_frown.gif
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,398
Tokens
Manila Gives Conflicting Signs on Iraq Pullout

by Alistair Lyon
(Reuters)

BAGHDAD -- Philippine officials, trying to save the life of a Filipino hostage, sent confusing signals on Tuesday about pulling troops out early from Iraq, while Australia said it would bolster its forces.

The Philippine army said it was ready to pull out of Iraq pending a formal order to do so after deputy foreign minister Rafael Seguis offered on television to withdraw Philippine forces as soon as possible.

But it was not clear if any pullout would be earlier than the August 20 date Manila had previously set for the withdrawal of its 50 troops that was set well before the hostage crisis.

The Islamic Army in Iraq group, which is threatening to behead 46-year-old truck driver Angelo de la Cruz, wants a withdrawal by July 20 in exchange for his freedom.

"We have not had an order from any office regarding the pullout," spokesman Daniel Lucero told Reuters. "We are prepared to implement our withdrawal plan."

Lucero said the plan had been in place since the 50-member humanitarian contingent was deployed to Iraq a year ago and could be quickly implemented.

Philippine officials were holding an emergency meeting at the foreign ministry.

Militants have seized dozens of foreigners since April to press demands for foreign troops to leave. Many hostages have been freed but at least three have been killed.

Spain withdrew its troops from Iraq after suspected al Qaeda-linked militants attacked packed Madrid commuter trains in March, killing 191 people, in what they said was revenge for Spanish involvement with U.S.-led forces. Honduras and the Dominican Republic later cut short their forces' stay in Iraq.

Monday, a roadside bomb killed two members of Iraq's 40,000 strong national guard as they conducted a foot patrol in Baghdad and wounded 14 others, the U.S. military said.

Peace and Mercy

Qatar-based Al Jazeera television showed Philippine deputy foreign minister Rafael Seguis offering to withdraw "as soon as possible" to save the life of de la Cruz.

Seguis was shown reading out a statement, which the television station translated into Arabic, shortly after the expiry of a new execution deadline set by the militants.

"In response to your request, the Philippines ... will withdraw its humanitarian forces as soon as possible," Seguis said according to the translation of the statement, addressed to the Islamic Army. He gave no date for a withdrawal.

"I hope the statement that I read will touch the heart of this group," said Seguis. "We know that Islam is the religion of peace and mercy."

CNN quoted unidentified Philippine officials as saying they expected de la Cruz to be released Tuesday.

The Islamic Army had extended a previous execution deadline by 24 hours for Manila to bow to demands for an early withdrawal after President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo's government in Manila vowed to stick to its original schedule.

"We certainly have heard nothing from the Philippine government other than what they have been saying, which is that they intend to maintain their presence through August (20th), said a State Department official, asking not to be named.

Al Jazeera, showing a letter it said it had received from the militants, reported earlier that de la Cruz had been moved "to the place of implementing the punishment."

It showed brief footage of a video tape showing de la Cruz standing in front of masked captors holding automatic weapons and said he appealed to Arroyo to swiftly withdraw troops from Iraq so he could return to his family alive.

At de la Cruz's family home in a rural area north of Manila, relatives prayed and lit candles with friends.

Australia Boosting Troops

Australia, a staunch U.S. ally, is boosting the number of its troops in Iraq to better protect diplomats and personnel training the Iraqi military, Defense Minister Robert Hill said.

Australia was doubling its light armored vehicles in Iraq to 12 and sending 30 extra army personnel, bringing the Australian security detachment to 120 and the total number of Australians on duty in and around Iraq to 880.

Bulgaria said it was confident two of its nationals held hostage in Iraq were alive despite the expiry of an execution deadline Friday.

Al Jazeera showed a video tape last week of the men being held by the Tawhid and Jihad group led by Jordanian militant Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, accused by Washington of links to al Qaeda.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
1,245
Tokens
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by lander:
American,
You write like a modern day rambo ...
why aren't you over there freeing captives instead of tough guy posting?

Oh, reality TV isn't fun when it's your own reality
icon_frown.gif
<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

Are you trying to say that Rambo collected O.J. Simpson rookie cards?

I did serve in the military, but I go out just before the Persian Gulf War, so I'm a little past my prime. I think I'd cause more problems over there than I'd solve. I wouldn't mind breaking out of retirement for you though.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
818
Tokens
"Manila says it will withdraw from Iraq"

I just hope Tonga and Costa Rica don't pull out - without them the center cannot hold.
icon_biggrin.gif
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
585
Tokens
Cowards. Them pope lovers over there will have a hard time pulling their tail out from under their legs but maybe their organ pullers will help with that. Jesse Ventura must have been speaking to them when he said that "organized religion was for the weak of mind."
Good luck Filipino catholics with all those terrorist Islamic scum living amongst you. You will need it.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
3,742
Tokens
Dumb move, the terrorist will now have even more of a field day in the Phillipines. We've tried to help these people, you can't do it all for them. Without a backbone they'll fall.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,398
Tokens
Manila Begins Withdrawal of Troops from Iraq

Saudi company also pulling out to appease kidnappers

040714_filipino_protest_hmed_8a.hmedium.jpg

Filipino protesters in Manila call for the withdrawal of Philippine troops from Iraq to save a Filipino worker held hostage by Iraqi militants.

(MSNBC)

MANILA -- The Philippines said Wednesday that it was withdrawing its small peacekeeping contingent from Iraq early to save a kidnapped truck driver, a dramatic turnaround by one of Washington’s biggest backers in the war on terrorism.

The Philippines had vowed earlier that it would not yield to pressure to move up its previously scheduled Aug. 20 withdrawal.

Meanwhile, a Saudi company also announced Wednesday that it would cease operations in Iraq to meet the demands of militants holding an Egyptian truck driver.

Wednesday’s announcement by the Philippines was a blow to the U.S.-led international contingent in Iraq, which has already been weakened by Spain’s pullout after the deadly terror attacks on Madrid’s train system in March. The move was criticized by other members of the coalition, who warned that it would increase the danger for other troops in Iraq.

The coalition also suffered a more palpable blow when a massive car bomb exploded at a checkpoint near an area housing international offices and embassies in Baghdad, killing at least 10 people and wounding 40 others, authorities said.

Attempt to Meet Demands

Captors holding the Philippine truck driver, Angelo dela Cruz, said they would treat him like a prisoner of war if Manila made a good-faith move toward withdrawing early. They said they would free him if the pullout was completed by next Tuesday.

040710_newhostage_hmed_7a.standard.jpg

Philippine hostage Angelo dela Cruz begs his government to withdraw troops from Iraq in a video shown Saturday on Al-Jazeera.

The Philippine government announced that it would try to meet the demand, although it was unclear when the withdrawal would be finished.

“What is important now is the safety of Angelo,” the government said in a statement. “There is a proper time for debate. Let us give the government enough time and our trust. With your support and unity, we will be able to resolve this problem with dignity as a nation.”

Dela Cruz’s family, hoping that his release was imminent, celebrated with a hearty breakfast of fish and fried chicken in their northern home province, Pampanga.

“We are happy that they are pulling out the troops already in exchange for my brother’s freedom,” Feliciano dela Cruz said.

Roy Cimatu, Manila’s special envoy for the Middle East, said the hostage was reported “alive and well.” “There’s no risk of execution of Angelo dela Cruz,” he told ABS-CBN television in Baghdad.

Washington had no immediate reaction. State Department spokesman Richard Boucher said Tuesday that a pullout would send “the wrong message” to hostage-takers and that the United States was continuing talks with Philippine authorities.

Allies Say Withdrawal Increases Danger

Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer warned the Philippine government Wednesday that all coalition countries in Iraq would “pay the price” for Manila’s decision, according to his spokesman.

A spokesman fore the Polish Foreign Ministry, Boguslaw Majewski, told Reuters that his country, which also has troops in Iraq, was sympathetic about the tough decision facing Philippine officials but had urged them to stand tough.

“The pullout by the Philippine government definitely increases danger for all other peace-keeping troops in Iraq. But I cannot say what Poland would do if we found ourselves in such an unfortunate situation,” he said.

The Iraqi Islamic Army-Khaled bin Al-Waleed Corps set a withdrawal deadline for the Philippines that expired Tuesday morning. But negotiations continued in Iraq through intermediaries.

The insurgents told President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo that dela Cruz, a poor father of eight, had been moved to the place he would be killed if she did not change her mind.

he crisis put Arroyo squarely between domestic concerns and her previously strong commitment to the United States, the Philippines’ former colonial power.

With Islamic and communist terror threats of its own, the Philippines has been relying on Washington to beef up its poorly armed military to battle al-Qaida-linked groups in the restive Muslim south.

There had been concerns that government concessions in Iraq could encourage local Muslim militants, such as the brutal Abu Sayyaf group.

Insurgents’ Strategy Bearing Fruit

Iraqi militants have repeatedly used terrorist attacks to try to force governments to withdraw from the U.S.-led occupation force.

Militants tried to pressure South Korea by kidnapping one of its citizens in Iraq and demanding that Seoul drop plans to deploy 3,000 troops beginning in August. South Korea refused, and the captive was beheaded last month.

The strategy also is aimed at persuading private companies not to send their employees to Iraq, and it bore fruit Wednesday when a Saudi company said it was ready to pull out of Iraq.

“We will withdraw our operation there to save the life of the hostage, our driver,” Faisal al-Neheit, owner of Faisal al-Neheit Transport Co., where Mohammed al-Gharabawi has worked for eight years, told Al-Jazeera television.

Al-Naheet said the kidnappers were also demanding $1 million ransom, but he said the company would not pay.

Al-Jazeera showed a videotape Tuesday of Iraq militants threatening to kill al-Gharabawi within 72 hours if the firm did not leave Iraq. They said he was snatched from a fuel truck he was driving from Saudi Arabia to the U.S. military in Iraq.

Last month, another Egyptian driver, Victor Tawfiq Gerges, was released after being held hostage by a militant group in Iraq for more than two weeks.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,398
Tokens
Serious questions for those who are downing the Phillipines over this:

(first, my opinion: it's a stupid move, not because of lack of loyalty to the U.S. but because it's stupid to negotiate with terrorists in the first place)

1) Lots of people seem to make of this basically that the Phillipines only had fifty people over there, so fúck the Phillipines. Relative to the size of its military and the fact that this war had absolutely no bearing on the Phillipines at all, fifty soliders plus the expense involved in sending them seems quite generous actually. You guys sound like a homeless person griping because a passerby gave him "only" a dollar.

2) Do you feel betrayed by the Phillipines; i.e. do you feel that some form of legal, military, trade or diplomatic repercussions are in order for their change of heart on the iraq issue?


Phaedrus
 

New member
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
3,742
Tokens
Phaedrus,

I know you know that the US has 200-300 troops operating in the Phillipines as we type. The Phillipines have a huge problem in their own country with radical muslim terrorist. This is only going to embolden the terrorist that are in place in the Phillipines. Extremely dumb move, 50 troops was noble, however the US has many more helping them as we type.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
5,398
Tokens
I would point out that the US has a very slightly larger military than the Phillipines.

It is true that we have helped them with their insurgent problem by providing troops and materiel. That is a good point.

I'm just mystified by the attitude that I see here and at other fora that basically runs along the two mentalities that either a) it's no big deal, screw those Filipino cowards, we don't need their 50 crossing guards anyway, and b) the Phillipine have betrayed out sacred trust and defaulted on their spiritual commitment to Warren Terrism etc.

Especially in the case of the latter, which group I cannot help but want to ask if that sort of "implied loyalty" also applied to the U.S., and if so does that mean that Saddam Hussein's hatred of our nation was justified after we backed him for years in the Iran-Iraq war only later to turn out that we were selling arms to the Iranians as well in Israeli-brokered deals. Somehow fair play, dignitiy and honour are the sort of things that Americans seem to expect from every government but their own.


Phaedrus
 

hangin' about
Joined
Aug 21, 2003
Messages
13,875
Tokens
The Filipino president is responding to the will of her people, who want to see the hostage home. She's not appeasing terrorists as I've heard so much, and not appeasing Americans by finishing a contract (with only 20 days left) that had a flawed premise to begin with. She owes only her own citizens who, reportedly, overwhelmingly want out of Iraq for the safety of this man. For a nation advocating regime change in the name of democracy, I find it laughable that some Americans choose not to respect this move.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,900
Messages
13,574,924
Members
100,882
Latest member
topbettor24
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com