Ok. Who should start, Eli or Warner!!??

Journeyman · Aug 23, 2004

Seems to be going to the wire...I personally believe Tom Coughlin already knows its Eli Manning, but wants to save face and make it look as if its still a competition....

Warner is disillusioned, still

!

Who do you feel should get the nod???

SurfBoard · Aug 23, 2004

warner for game 1. then manning comes in forthe giants goes 15-0

thats what you want to hear, right?

JohnnyDeMarco · Aug 23, 2004

If the Giants O line is decent he should start Manning. If it is suspect start Warner.

JimFiestSux · Aug 23, 2004

Give the "KID" the ball from the GetGo! He'll be fine!

GreenDoberman · Aug 23, 2004

Start Warner, have him get hurt, then bring in Eli. With that O-line, "The Bachelor" could be playing by week 6.

Journeyman · Aug 23, 2004

'The Bachelor'

"I'm a lover, not a player"

sherman · Aug 23, 2004

<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Journeyman:
'The Bachelor'
http://images.sportsline.com/images/football/nfl/players/60x80/235137.jpg

"I'm a lover, not a player"

Marco · Aug 23, 2004

All Warner has done since his thumb injury is fumble and throw int's....his best days are behind him...

Why the Giants picked him up is beyond me....

Give Eli a chance or the Giants have no chance.

stlrocker · Aug 23, 2004

They should give the ball to Brenda Warner.

Rock On,
\,,/ \,,/

Railbird · Aug 23, 2004

Coughlin is a scumbag.

Guest · Aug 23, 2004

It won't matter Journey....they open with us so they have no chance of winning.

As for the real answer to your question they should let Eli sit the first quarter against us because that's about how long it will take for Kurt to get hurt (which the Eagles would probably do to him with the blitz packages).

sb