Here are all their top 4* plays he released so far this college season, the first play listed is their TOP PLAY, I went through and re-counted them all (was off slightly from my above post, but basically the same):
8/30
4* Wisconsin
Winner Top Play
4* Miss St
Loser
9/6
4* Auburn
Loser Top Play
4* Tennessee
Loser
4* Notre Dame
Loser
9/13
4* Nebraska
Loser Top Play
4* Purdue
Winner
4* Kansas
Winner
9/20
5* Ariz St
Loser Top Play
4* LSU
Winner
4* Illinois
Loser
4* NC State
Winner
9/27
4* Florida
Loser Top Play
4* Kansas
Winner
4* BYU
Loser
10/4
4* Michigan
Loser Top Play
4* Nebraska
Winner
4* Maryland
Winner
8-10 (44%) winners on 5 Star and 4 Star Plays. Only 1 win, 5 losses on his top play "
The strongest rated college play anywhere". These are the big ones. Combined with the 3 star games, the season total is 15-19 (44%).
The 2 Star games, even according to Phil, do not count towards the overall "monitored record" and on the STAR BASIS, he is Down and you could not of won money playing these plays based on the Star rated plays. Far from "WAY UP". Unless, for some reason, you played all the 2 stars the same as his 4 stars, which makes no sense since the 4 star plays are the "Stronger" plays. He doesn't count them when they lose against his record, so you cannot count them for his record if they win. They are JUST "Opinion" plays. The 3 star and higher plays are the ones that are rated and monitored.
Now in the NFL, its the Complete Opposite and he's 10-4-1, and is 4-1 with his top weekly NFL Plays. Definately Kicking Asss in the pro's, no doubt about it and kudo's for that. But we are just talking about College and in College, for the 2nd year in a row, he's flat out sucked, the record speaks for itself.
If you bet his college plays, You are definately down. How far down depends on how much you play per game, or Per star. I was with Northcoast 3 or 4 years ago and had the entire season and was told, depending on Bankroll size, that a good "outline" was Top College plays you should bet a little more than normal 4*s if you'd like,$450, or just as regular 4*'s at $400, 3*'s $200, 2*'s $100 or less if at all. That is how hey broke it down for College based on how much I was betting on Average from Northcoast Themselves.
15-19 Overall
1-5 Top 4* and 5* plays
1 win = +$450
5 losses = -$2250
-$225 commision
-$2025 for top plays
7-5 other 4* plays not top plays
7 wins = +$2800
5 losses = -$2000
-$200 Commision
+$600 for other 4* plays
7-9 on 3* plays
7 wins = +$1400
9 losses = -$1800
-$180 Commision
-$580 on 3* plays
Based on this outline, some will be different based on dollar values, how much per game, ect ect, overall you should be
DOWN -$2005. Not including if you are paying for the picks. With just the 4 star or higher,
Down -$1425. Springle in the 2* selections you may play (we'll say they won 8 lost 4), I'll give you a profit of $400 and you are still down big time.
As you can tell, I have a lot of time on my hands, (under the weather)
***He is doing well in the pro's and is definately putting you Way Up if you are just playing the pros. Combining the College and Pro season, you wouldn't be down as bad as if you JUST played college, but you would still be in the hole. And for a "College Expert", this performance (last year was almost just as bad) is horrible.