manning or warner

gtc08 · Oct 1, 2008

1 pt 25 pass yards 1 pt 10 rush yards 6 pts td -2 pts int, lost fumble

manning at home vs. seattle

warner at home vs. buffalo

leaning manning, warner the more explosive pick though

Mr_Mark · Oct 2, 2008

warner is coming off a good game despite the turnovers and manning is coming off a bye week without plaxico. i would start warner

JakeT. · Oct 3, 2008

Both guys have decent matchups but Buffalo's defense is poor IMO and I think Warner can do nicely. Like mr mark pointed out, Plax is gone as well so go Warner.

theriddler01 · Oct 5, 2008

Start Manning. Hixon will be taking Plax's spot and he and Manning have a great relationship. If you saw him play in the preseason against Cleve you know what he can do. Manning will still have Toomer as well. Seahawks have a prob stopping the pass. I say Manning.

artiesliver · Oct 5, 2008

I say Manning. Plax out also allows Amani to get more looks and Amani w/o Plax is the man.

gtc08 · Oct 5, 2008

decided on warner. hes just more explosive. gigantes a more ball control type team. ithink both can put up 17+ points. i just see more potential out of warner.