sdf, the NFL says, hey bro' if the going gets too tough, it's time to bail. The NCAA should realize this and get off their high horse. Their penalties can be tossed in the trash with nothing more than a whim. Ask Pete Carrol.
In principle I agree with everything you are saying. Everyone has to play by the same rules written the way they are written. But as long as Reggie Bush doesn't have to pay back his NFL signing bonus, and as long as USC or anyone else that gets the same treatment from NCAA infractions investigations doesn't have to pay back the money they were paid at the time, nothing the NCAA does will have any kind of lasting effect and that will never happen. The BCS and the conferences control the purse strings. Perhaps in the short term some players and some schools will cool it, but it won't ever be for very long as long as the NCAA remains as slow to act as they are (under great duress from the BCS to leave things be) and as long as the NFL keeps dangling carrots in front of college football players enticing them to leave school early. "Take the money and run" will remain a powerful influence and a viable choice as long as money is at the heart of the matter. It's human nature. It's also a human need, and I'm not just talking about Gucci shoes.
Even in RB's situtuation, giving back the Heisman was merely a self administered slap on the wrist compared to paying back all of his so called "ill gotten" gains. By his play, he still deserved it and everyone knows it. He does too. According to the rules, he also deserved to give it back and he did. What he does later in the NFL hardly changes anything he gets from the NFL when he leaves college football. His name alone deserves a reward. So it goes in the entertainment business. Money does't speak, it swears loudly. Some things will never change.
To me that is the driving force from which I have come to the conclusion that the rules just aren't set up right anymore. The threat of punishment without the possibility of reward has long been acknowledged as a failed approch to influencing human behavior. It assumes fear based reasoning behind motivation will solve things and perhaps for a year or two it may. But in the long run, that creates rebelliousness not compliance.
As long as the pressures coming at players from two opposite directions are not acknowledged for what they are and the rules are not changed to address today's issues and today's problems, it's only logical that players and coaches and football programs will be torn in two opposite directions, constantly being pushed into the gray area and over the line too often. The little voice in their head says it's time to rebel, test things. Is this the devil's advocate or is it common sense? One thing for certainis that it's a part of human nature and either the NCAA realizes this and accepts it and then does something about it or this will go on until they destroy themselves over it. In the long run, nothing will change, only get worse.
The rules are such that making right choices isn't an easy thing to do anymore. The NFL accepts college drop outs. They pay them big signing bonuses. Even if a player doesn't make that cut, he can still command a million dollars every year or two wherever he goes, even in the CFL. Just like in Pryor's situation, what's to lose? A slap on the wrist and then the NFL says to him, don't worry about that, everything is going to be fine. Or maybe some player blows out a knee one spring day and it all goes poof. Then what? (Ask Oregon State's all-American wideout James Rogers what he thinks about all of this. He HAS to play another year because he blew out his knee right before the end of his junior season. His younger brother Quizz was luckier and now he's gone.) Just look at what that scenario has done to the college football recruiting game? Has it ever mattered as much as it does now because of that simple shift in the ground rules every player sees? And does that bug the coaches?
That's plenty for now. It could take me weeks to get this all out of my system.
I never much cared for Ohio State any way.