If you were starting a team.....

[sherman]

and you had to draft these 5 players for ONE season, in what order would you take them? Mine are in order from first to last.....

Albert Pujols
Manny Ramirez
Ichiro
Derek Jeter
Miguel Tejada

 

[BAUS]

Kind of a weak list....what would you do with 2 SS's ?

I would take Ichiro first and convert him to a catcher...

BAUS

 

[sherman]

long story as to why the list is the way it is......let's just say a friendly disagreement......

 

[royalfan]

Pujols a clear first. The rest are somewhat interchangeable based on need.

 

[WildBill]

How long are you looking out? Just on age alone Pujols is a clear first. The other guys don't have that many great years left in them, unless they plan on improving like Barry Bonds has into his late 30s. Good players on that list, but if all I wanted was one big year I would take a healthy Bonds over anyone. I know his image is so heavily tarnished, but what he accomplished over the last few years is nothing short of incredible. None of these guys came close to matching Bonds' sheer offensive creation, nor do they change the whole strategy of other teams as Bonds does.

 

[PatPatriot]

Jeter easy.

 

[UWinSports]

Jeter easy.

You must be on drugs. The guy is a average player surrounded by great players.

 

[JudgeWapner]

Pujols.