Oren, keep something else in mind. You tend to skew towards the over all the time. Remember that you tend to be biased, for whatever reason. Almost every week you think that these films will go over. Remember our little discussion on Anger Management?
As for the Score, you said it....19 mil, in wider release than this one. Secondly, this film does NOT have a Robert Deniro along side Norton (Charlize Theron and Marky Mark are NO Deniros). Thirdly, this film has just as much, if not MORE competition as the Score, with X2, Matrix, Finding Nemo, Bruce Almighty.
I think with your post, you really helped out the argument for the UNDER, not the OVER.
JP