My rationale for PHI/NY UNDER 51.5
My secret weapon this year has been playing Phi Team Total UNDERS. I have been playing them most weeks when they are above 24 and it almost always wins. But because of the Chip situation and the fact they are on the road against the Giants (who might want to send Coughlin out win a win) they are dogs and the team total is only 23.5 (you can probably get 24 at 5 dimes with extra juice). I think 24 is a key number with totals so rather than take the PHI TT I will go for the game total which is an inflated 51.5. The Giants have scored 20 or fewer in 3 of the last 5. Phi has scored 24 or less in 4 of the last 5 and the one time they went OVER was when they got two ST TDs and a Defensive TD vs NE, which was an abnormal game and didn't reflect a strong offense.
And, most of all, I don't need these teams to play great defense. 52 points is a lot even when teams look decent on offense. If even one offense doesn't show up today the chances of this hitting are strong. I could see a scenario where a Chip-less eagles feel free and blow up on offense, but I think it is more than likely the opposite will happen, especially with their weak QB and WRs. The Giants are certainly capable of scoring a lot, but they are inconsistent -- as I noted they have scored 20 or less in 3 of the last 5 (and I can afford for them to score more than that and keep an UNDER pace -- their TT is 28 (28!). So even if they score 28 there is a decent chance this game will go under. I have two units on this but I am thinking of adding to it. My biggest fear is the PHI defense just implodes as they did vs Wash (38) and Arizona (40). But those teams are red hot, the Giants aren't. They are an inconsistent team capable of lots of scoring, but equally capable of mediocrity. And mediocrity is what I expect from both team today. I see a final of something like 23-20 Giants.