Also its not far fetched at all that even if the registrar is not US based.......that they end up complying with the court order
Order of magnitude less likely, that a foreign company will comply with a U.S. court order -- esp. if laws don't mesh up. Otherwise you'd have seen AllOfMP3.com taken down a long time ago, rather than the U.S. forcing the Russians to do it in WTO negotations.
Of course, perhaps someone ought to start an ICANN-certified registrar in Costa Rica.
If they can't get what they want from the registrar, they aren't going to go to ICANN nor the dot-com Root (managed by Verisign) because it's already too political that these are still under U.S. government supervision.
I am actually surprised that Network Solutions stood their ground in this situation
Did they? I'm not surprised, Network Solutions is a Verisign subsidiary, they start complying and pretty soon they're going to get legal requests for any of the 77 million dot-com domains.